Statement #o3 Discussion

Below is the statement as it appears with the fallacy marked as correct. You can see the totals of most frequent responses to this statement. And after reading the any discussion going on below, you can select your choice(s) for the correct answer. For now, whoever posts each statement can update corrections.

Bill: "Smoking is very unhealthy and leads to all sorts of problems. So take my advice and never start."
Jill: "Well, I certainly don't want to get cancer."
Bill: "I'm going to get a smoke. Want to join me Dave?"
Jill: "Well, I guess smoking can't be that bad. After all, Bill smokes."

Ad Hominem Tu Quoque
AKA "You Too Fallacy"
Category: Fallacies of Relevance (Red Herrings) → Ad hominems (Genetic Fallacies)

This fallacy is committed when it is concluded that a person's claim is false because 1) it is inconsistent with something else a person has said or 2) what a person says is inconsistent with her actions. This type of "argument" has the following form:

Person A makes claim X.
Person B asserts that A's actions or past claims are inconsistent with the truth of claim X.
Therefore X is false.

The fact that a person makes inconsistent claims does not make any particular claim he makes false (although of any pair of inconsistent claims only one can be true-but both can be false). Also, the fact that a person's claims are not consistent with his actions might indicate that the person is a hypocrite but this does not prove his claims are false.

Ad Hominem Tu Quoque

928 Total Answer Attempts 35%
321 Correctly Popped Fallacies
607 Incorrectly Un/Popped

Example from LaBossiere's Forty Two Fallacies

( Random Image )

Most Common Responses

321 - Ad Hominem Tu Quoque
62 - Appeal to Popularity
58 - Peer Pressure
56 - Appeal to Common Practice
35 - Appeal to Authority
29 - Relativist Fallacy
24 - Biased Generalization
21 - Appeal to the Consequences of a Belief
21 - Hasty Generalization
20 - Special Pleading
20 - Ignoring a Common Cause
17 - Circumstantial Ad Hominem
17 - Genetic Fallacy
17 - Appeal to Belief
16 - Confusing Cause and Effect
16 - Red Herring
16 - Fallacy of Composition
15 - Gambler's Fallacy
14 - Misleading Vividness
12 - False Dilemma
12 - Burden of Proof
11 - Fallacy of Division
10 - Guilt by Association
9 - Slippery Slope
9 - Poisoning the Well
8 - Appeal to Fear
8 - Ad Hominem
8 - Middle Ground
7 - Appeal to Tradition
7 - Post Hoc
7 - Appeal to Novelty
6 - Begging the Question
6 - Appeal to Emotion
4 - Appeal to Flattery
4 - Appeal to Pity
2 - Personal Attack
2 - Appeal to Ridicule
1 -

Likes for Correct Answers

Show all on page ↑

0 Threads with 0 Comments

+	Type in your comment here...

Play Game - Fallacy List - Add Statements - Player Collections - Discussions

Login - High Scores - About - Trivium - Links - Contact

Donate To DontFallacy.Me - Support Dr. Labossiere

Creative Commons, 2014, Wiki World Order (Morgan Lesko)

* Fallacious statements are usually paired with a random image of a person who never spoke those words.
This free site is for educational purposes, studying intellectual dishonesty. The images are being used under fair use. Sunflower by robstephaustrali.